Staten Island

Best Pizza in Staten Island

4 restaurants, ranked

Every pizza we track in Staten Island, ranked.

Denino's Pizzeria

4.6

Port Richmond · Staten Island · $$

Pizza

Top rated

Crowd favorite

Serving Staten Island since 1937, this tavern-style institution turns out crackery thin-crust pies, with the garlic-and-pepperoni MJ a longtime local favorite.

Joe & Pat's

4.5

Castleton Corners · Staten Island · $$

Pizza

Crowd favorite

The ultra-thin, cracker-crisp crust here is a Staten Island benchmark, best ordered with the vodka sauce that turned this 1960 parlor into a borough legend.

Domino's

New Dorp-Midland Beach · Staten Island

Pizza

Domino's is a New Dorp-Midland Beach spot for pizza.

Papa John's

New Dorp-Midland Beach · Staten Island

Pizza

Papa John's is a New Dorp-Midland Beach spot for pizza.